Etsy charges you a percentage of every sale, no matter how small your shop is. Big Cartel charges you a flat monthly fee and takes nothing extra when you sell.
Get More Etsy Seller Tips Like This
New seller guides and marketplace tips, straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Table of Contents
- Why This Comparison Matters
- Etsy Overview
- Big Cartel Overview
- Head-to-Head: Pricing & Fees
- Head-to-Head: Features
- Head-to-Head: Ease of Use
- Traffic and Discoverability
- Who Should Choose Etsy?
- Who Should Choose Big Cartel?
- Migration Guide: Moving from Etsy to Big Cartel
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The Bottom Line
Why This Comparison Matters
If your Etsy shop only sells a handful of items a month, the marketplace’s per-sale fees can feel disproportionate to what you’re actually bringing in. That’s the exact question this guide answers: does it make sense to stay on Etsy, or does a small flat-fee platform like Big Cartel keep more of your money in your pocket?
We’ll walk through both platforms’ real pricing structures, side by side, using their published fee and plan pages. Then we’ll cover the features, setup effort, and traffic tradeoffs that matter for a shop small enough that every dollar of margin counts.
Here’s exactly how it breaks down.
Etsy Overview
Etsy is a marketplace, not a storefront builder. Sellers list products inside an existing marketplace with its own built-in shopper traffic, search engine, and buyer trust signals.
Key strengths:
- Built-in buyer traffic; shoppers arrive already looking to buy handmade or vintage goods
- No design or technical setup required to start listing
- Buyer protection and dispute handling are built into the platform
Key weaknesses:
- Every sale is taxed by multiple stacked fees, regardless of shop size
- Sellers don’t own their customer relationship or email list by default
- Search ranking and Offsite Ads exposure are controlled by Etsy’s algorithm, not the seller
Pricing summary: Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee per item, a 6.5% transaction fee on the total sale price including shipping, and a payment processing fee that varies by country (3% + $0.25 in the US). See Etsy’s official fee page for current rates by region.
Big Cartel Overview
Big Cartel is an independent storefront platform built specifically for small makers and artists. You pay a flat monthly fee for hosting and tools, and the store is entirely yours.
Key strengths:
- No per-sale transaction fee charged by the platform itself
- A free tier exists for very small catalogs, with no monthly cost at all
- Full ownership of the storefront, customer data, and branding
Key weaknesses:
- No built-in shopper traffic, so you have to bring your own buyers
- Product catalog size is capped by plan tier
- Fewer built-in marketing and SEO tools than a marketplace search engine provides
Pricing summary: Big Cartel’s Gold plan is free for up to 5 products, Platinum runs $9.99/month for up to 25 products, and Diamond runs $19.99/month for up to 50 products. See Big Cartel’s pricing page for the current plan breakdown.
Head-to-Head: Pricing & Fees
This is where the two platforms diverge the most. Etsy’s fees scale with your revenue: the more you sell, the more you pay in absolute dollars. Big Cartel’s core plan cost is fixed, so the fee burden shrinks as a percentage of revenue the more you sell.
| Fee Type | Etsy | Big Cartel |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly plan | $0 (pay-as-you-list) | $0–$19.99/mo depending on product count |
| Listing fee | $0.20 per item, per 4-month cycle | None |
| Transaction fee | 6.5% of sale total (incl. shipping) | None (platform-level) |
| Payment processing | ~3% + $0.25 (US, via Etsy Payments) | ~2.9% + $0.30 (via Stripe or PayPal) |
| Offsite Ads fee | 12–15% on attributed sales, capped at $100/order | Not applicable |
Disclaimer: Fees change over time on both platforms. Always verify current rates on Etsy’s official fee page and Big Cartel’s pricing page before making a decision.
Here’s the deal: on a $40 sale, Etsy’s stacked fees (listing, transaction, and payment processing) typically run close to $4.50–$5.00 total. On Big Cartel, that same sale only carries the payment processor’s cut, roughly $1.46, plus whatever slice of your monthly plan fee you attribute to it. For a shop doing consistent volume, that difference compounds fast.
How the Fees Add Up at Different Sales Volumes
Numbers make this concrete. Using a $40 average order value and Big Cartel’s Platinum plan ($9.99/month), here’s roughly what total platform costs look like at three sales levels:
| Monthly Sales | Est. Total Etsy Fees | Est. Total Big Cartel Fees |
|---|---|---|
| $500/mo (~12 orders) | ~$53 | ~$28 |
| $2,000/mo (~50 orders) | ~$213 | ~$83 |
| $5,000/mo (~125 orders) | ~$531 | ~$192 |
These figures are illustrative estimates based on published fee percentages, not a guarantee of your exact costs. Your average order value, shipping charges, and whether Offsite Ads gets attributed to a sale will all shift the real number. But the pattern holds at every volume tested: because Etsy’s fees scale with revenue and Big Cartel’s core cost doesn’t, the gap between the two widens as sales grow, not shrinks.
The takeaway: a slow month barely moves the needle on which platform is “cheaper,” but a shop doing consistent five-figure annual revenue is very likely paying Etsy multiples of what the same volume would cost on a flat-fee plan.
Head-to-Head: Features & Automation
Etsy’s feature set is built around marketplace mechanics: listing management, Offsite Ads, Etsy Ads (on-platform promoted listings), and Star Seller tracking. Most of these tools exist to help you compete for visibility inside Etsy’s own search results, not to grow an audience you control.
Big Cartel’s feature set is built around running an independent shop: custom domain support, inventory tracking, discount codes, and (on the Diamond plan) abandoned cart recovery and scheduled product drops. Email marketing, SEO, and traffic generation are left to you or third-party integrations, since Big Cartel doesn’t have a built-in shopper base to promote you to.
Head-to-Head: Ease of Use
Etsy is faster to start selling on. You create a shop, add listings, and you’re visible in marketplace search within minutes, with no design decisions required.
Big Cartel requires more upfront setup: choosing a theme, customizing your storefront, and connecting a payment processor. It’s still built for non-technical sellers, but expect an afternoon of setup rather than a few minutes.
Traffic and Discoverability
This is the tradeoff that fee tables alone don’t capture. Etsy’s biggest asset is the shoppers already searching the marketplace with intent to buy, not its tools. A new Etsy listing can get discovered by someone who has never heard of your shop.
Big Cartel has no equivalent built-in audience. A Big Cartel store only gets traffic you drive to it yourself, through social media, paid ads, search engine optimization, or an email list. If you don’t already have a following or a marketing plan, a lower fee structure won’t matter if nobody finds the shop. For sellers weighing this exact tradeoff, our breakdown of Etsy vs Shopify for handmade sellers covers the same traffic-versus-fees calculation in more depth.
Who Should Choose Etsy?
- You’re just starting out and need buyer traffic you haven’t built yet
- Your product category has strong existing search demand on Etsy
- You sell low volume and the per-sale fees stay small in absolute dollars
- You don’t yet have the time or audience to market an independent store
- You want built-in buyer trust and dispute protection without setting it up yourself
Who Should Choose Big Cartel?
- You already have some following: social media, email list, or repeat customers
- Your catalog is small (under 25 products fits comfortably on Platinum, under 50 on Diamond)
- You sell at consistent volume where percentage-based fees add up fast
- You want full control over branding, pricing, and customer data
- You’re comfortable handling your own marketing and traffic generation
Migration Guide: Moving from Etsy to Big Cartel
- Export your Etsy listing data. Etsy’s Shop Manager lets you download a CSV of your current listings, including titles, descriptions, and prices, so you’re not rewriting everything from scratch.
- Sign up for a Big Cartel plan that fits your current catalog size. Start on Gold (free) if you’re under 5 products, or Platinum if you need more room.
- Recreate your listings using the exported data, uploading fresh product photos sized for your new theme.
- Connect a payment processor (Stripe or PayPal) to Big Cartel before your store can accept live payments.
- Set up a custom domain if you want a branded URL rather than a bigcartel.com subdomain.
- Start building an email list immediately. See our full Etsy fee breakdown for the math on exactly why this is urgent.
- Run both shops in parallel for a few weeks before pointing all your marketing at the new store, so you don’t lose sales during the transition.
Realistically, budget a weekend for the initial setup and a few weeks of parallel operation before fully relying on the new store for income.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Big Cartel cheaper than Etsy?
For sellers with consistent sales volume, Big Cartel is usually cheaper because its cost is a flat monthly fee rather than a percentage of every sale. For very low-volume sellers, Etsy’s pay-as-you-list model with no monthly minimum can work out cheaper in absolute dollars.
Does Big Cartel charge transaction fees?
No, Big Cartel itself does not charge a transaction fee on sales. You still pay your payment processor’s standard rate, typically around 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction through Stripe or PayPal.
Which platform is better for beginners?
Etsy is easier for a first-time seller because it comes with built-in shopper traffic and requires no store design decisions. Big Cartel takes more setup time and depends on the seller bringing their own traffic.
How long does migrating from Etsy to Big Cartel take?
Basic setup, including creating a store, connecting payments, and recreating listings, can be done in a weekend for a small catalog. Most sellers run both shops in parallel for a few weeks before fully switching over.
Are there hidden fees on either platform?
Etsy sellers should watch for Offsite Ads fees (12–15% on attributed sales), which apply automatically unless you qualify for opt-out. Big Cartel sellers should budget for a custom domain (usually $10–$20/year) and any app integrations beyond what’s included in their plan.
Can you run an Etsy shop and a Big Cartel store at the same time?
Yes. Many sellers keep an Etsy shop open for marketplace discovery while building a Big Cartel store as their owned, fee-lighter sales channel.
Which platform has better SEO tools?
Etsy has its own internal search algorithm that ranks listings within the marketplace, which functions differently from traditional web SEO. Big Cartel stores rely on standard external SEO and a seller’s own content or marketing to be found on Google.
Which platform has better customer support?
Big Cartel’s Diamond plan includes priority human support. Etsy’s support is primarily self-service help articles and a support ticket system, with response times that vary by season and support volume.
What happens to your listings if you cancel Big Cartel?
Your storefront goes offline if you don’t renew a paid plan or downgrade below your product count, but you retain your own exported product data and customer information, since Big Cartel doesn’t hold marketplace-style control over your customer relationships.
Does Etsy or Big Cartel handle inventory syncing better?
Both platforms offer basic inventory tracking. Etsy’s is built for marketplace listings tied to search visibility, while Big Cartel’s is built for a standalone store and integrates with limited third-party inventory apps depending on plan tier.
Is Big Cartel only for artists, or can any small shop use it?
Big Cartel was originally built for independent artists and makers, but its plans and tools work for any small catalog seller who wants a flat-fee, self-owned storefront rather than a marketplace listing.
The Bottom Line
Etsy and Big Cartel solve different problems. Etsy sells you access to an existing audience in exchange for a percentage of every sale. Big Cartel sells you a storefront you fully control in exchange for a flat fee and the responsibility of finding your own buyers.
If you’re a new seller without an audience yet, or your volume is low enough that Etsy’s per-sale fees stay small in dollar terms, stay on Etsy while you build traction. If you already have some following and your sales volume is consistent enough that percentage fees are eating a real chunk of your margin, Big Cartel’s flat-fee model likely saves you money, as long as you’re ready to own your own marketing.
Compare your exact fee breakdown with our Etsy fee guide before deciding which path fits your shop.
Related Articles
- Etsy Fee Increases in 2026: The Full Seller Breakdown: a full line-item breakdown of every current Etsy fee.
- Etsy vs Shopify for Handmade Sellers: Fees Compared (2026): how Etsy’s fee structure compares to a larger independent store platform.
- Etsy vs Amazon Handmade: Which Fits Your Shop (2026): another marketplace-versus-marketplace comparison for handmade sellers.
- How Women’s Shoe Sellers Can Build Their Own Store: a category-specific look at leaving Etsy for an independent shop.
- How Video Game Etsy Sellers Can Build Their Own Store: another category-specific transition guide with practical migration steps.
About This Research
Chloe Cruz has spent the last four years writing about eCommerce and marketplace selling, and writes Marketplace Hackers’ guides on Etsy fees, platform comparisons, and store growth. She writes Marketplace Hackers’ guides on Etsy fees, platform comparisons, and store growth.
This comparison is based on a direct review of Etsy’s and Big Cartel’s published fee and pricing pages as of August 2026, cross-referenced against third-party Etsy fee-tracking data to confirm current transaction and payment processing rates.
Content reviewed and updated: 2026-08-11
Connect With Us
Have a question about leaving Etsy or comparing platforms for your shop? Reach out through our contact page, or subscribe to our newsletter for more category-specific breakdowns like this one.
Want More Marketplace Tips?
Join the newsletter — new guides drop regularly.