“Within 48 hours, our sales were three to four times what they had ever been.” (Erin Hooley, founder, Bailey’s Blossoms)
Get More Etsy Seller Tips Like This
New seller guides and marketplace tips, straight to your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Background: A Kitchen-Table Etsy Shop
- The Strategy: Turn a Platform Problem Into a Brand Asset
- Step 1: Build the Habit of Owning the Customer Relationship
- Step 2: Move Fast When Etsy Pulls the Rug
- Step 3: Reinvest the Etsy-Fee Savings Into Owned Channels
- Step 4: Diversify Into a Second Brand
- The Results
- Key Lessons
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The Bottom Line
Introduction
In this case study, we’re going to show you exactly how a Texas mom of six turned a kitchen-table Etsy shop into a children’s clothing business now doing roughly $6 million a year. This is not an anonymous success story pulled from a marketing brochure. Founder Erin Hooley has walked through her numbers on the record in multiple interviews, so the timeline and figures here can be checked against her own words.
The twist is that Bailey’s Blossoms did not leave Etsy by choice. Etsy removed the shop from the platform in December 2015, and Hooley had to rebuild her revenue on her own website within weeks. Here’s the step-by-step breakdown of what happened, and why losing her Etsy shop turned out to be the best thing for the business.
Background: A Kitchen-Table Etsy Shop
Erin Hooley started Bailey’s Blossoms in March 2009, selling handmade hair clips from her kitchen table in Arizona. She was a stay-at-home mother of six by age 28, with no formal business training and, by her own account, no sewing skills (Starter Story). She listed her first product on Etsy and, within five days, had also set up a standalone website and a Facebook page.
That early decision to run a website alongside the Etsy shop mattered later, but for years Etsy carried the business. The product line grew from hair clips into DIY tutu kits, then into a full line of ready-to-wear infant and toddler clothing. By the mid-2010s, Etsy sales made up about 85% of total revenue, and the shop had grown into roughly $600,000 a year, making it one of Etsy’s biggest shops overall (Mixergy interview with Erin Hooley).
That concentration was the risk nobody could see yet. When a single marketplace accounts for the majority of a shop’s revenue, any policy change at that marketplace becomes an existential threat, not an inconvenience. For a detailed breakdown of what marketplace dependence actually costs a seller, see our guide to Etsy’s current fee structure.
The Strategy: Turn a Platform Problem Into a Brand Asset
Most Etsy sellers plan an exit on their own timeline, if they plan one at all. Bailey’s Blossoms didn’t get that choice. In December 2015, Etsy removed the shop, ruling that Hooley’s ready-to-wear clothing line no longer met the platform’s handmade requirements (Mixergy interview).
Instead of treating the removal as a catastrophe, Hooley leaned on the website and Facebook following she had already spent years building. She emailed and messaged customers directly, pointed them to her own site, and had the business back on stable footing within days. What follows below is less a strategy than a sequence of moves, made possible only because the owned audience already existed before it was needed.
Step 1: Build the Habit of Owning the Customer Relationship
What she did: From the first week of the business, Hooley ran a standalone website and Facebook page in parallel with the Etsy shop, even while Etsy carried most of the sales volume.
Why this over Etsy-only selling: Etsy does not give sellers a customer’s email address or full contact details by default. A shop that sells exclusively through Etsy has no direct way to reach its own buyers if the platform relationship changes.
How she executed it: Facebook became the primary engagement channel. Hooley ran monthly photo contests, called “Cutie Contests,” that generated 600 to 700 customer photo submissions a month, which she then used as the bulk of her marketing imagery (Starter Story).
Legal disclaimer: Bailey’s Blossoms’ revenue and growth figures come from Erin Hooley’s own on-the-record interviews. Results vary by product category, existing audience, and execution, and none of this is a guarantee of similar outcomes for any other seller.
Step 2: Move Fast When Etsy Pulls the Rug
What she did: When Etsy removed the shop in December 2015, Hooley moved the entire operation to her own website within weeks rather than appealing for reinstatement or pausing sales.
Why speed mattered: A children’s clothing brand with an active customer base loses momentum fast if buyers cannot find a place to purchase. Every day without a working sales channel was lost revenue and a chance for customers to forget the brand.
The result of moving fast: Sales on her own website reached three to four times their previous level within 48 hours of the shift away from Etsy, according to Hooley’s account (Starter Story). She has said the jump made clear that brand recognition and social media, not Etsy’s internal search, had been driving demand for some time.
If your shop currently depends on Etsy for most of its revenue, our guide on building an email list before leaving Etsy covers how to start that owned-audience work before a policy change forces the issue.
Step 3: Reinvest the Etsy-Fee Savings Into Owned Channels
What she did: With transaction fees, payment processing fees, and offsite ads fees no longer coming out of every sale, Hooley redirected that margin into email, SMS, and paid social campaigns run directly by the business.
Why this over relying on organic reach: By 2020, email campaigns were generating close to 20% of monthly revenue, and SMS campaigns were contributing roughly 12% and growing, according to Hooley’s interview with Starter Story that year. Paid Facebook and Instagram advertising was returning 4.85 times the ad spend for the core Bailey’s Blossoms brand.
How she executed it: User-generated content stayed central to the marketing mix. Roughly 85% of the images used across the website and ad creative in 2020 came from customer photo submissions rather than staged product photography (Starter Story).
“We didn’t have a marketing budget when we started. We had customers who wanted to show off their kids.” (Paraphrased from Erin Hooley’s account of the brand’s early photo-contest strategy)
Step 4: Diversify Into a Second Brand
What she did: Bailey’s Blossoms launched a sister label, Peyton Bre, extending the same customer base into a second product line rather than only scaling the original brand.
Why this over doubling down on one brand: A second brand spreads risk across more products and price points and gives the business more than one growth lever. By 2018, Bailey’s Blossoms and Peyton Bre combined had grown the company to roughly $6 million a year, up sharply from the roughly $600,000 the Etsy shop alone had generated a few years earlier, and the company landed on the Inc. 5000 list of fastest-growing private companies two years in a row (Mixergy interview; Inc.).
How she executed it: The launch was not without cost. Hooley has said the business lost roughly $2 million on Peyton Bre due to overly optimistic inventory projections when the label first launched in a direct-to-consumer model (Starter Story). She has been public about that loss as a lesson in forecasting demand for a brand-new label separately from an established one.
The Results
233% year-over-year sales growth in 2016, the year Etsy removed the shop and forced the move to an owned site.
| Metric | Around 2015 (Etsy era) | By 2018-2020 (post-Etsy) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual revenue, core brand | ~$600,000 | ~$6,000,000 | Mixergy interview |
| Share of revenue from Etsy | ~85% | 0% (removed Dec. 2015) | Mixergy interview |
| Sales growth after the Etsy exit | – | 3-4x within 48 hours; 233% YoY in 2016 | Starter Story; Mixergy |
| Sister-brand revenue (Peyton Bre) | $0 | ~$2,000,000/year | Mixergy interview |
| Monthly revenue (2020 update) | – | ~$750,000/month | Starter Story |
| Total customer base | – | ~750,000 | Starter Story |
| Workforce | 1 (Hooley alone) | 35 employees, 25,000 sq ft warehouse | Starter Story |
The single biggest driver of the jump was not a new product or a paid ad campaign. It was the audience Hooley had already built on her own website and Facebook page before she ever needed it. When Etsy stopped being an option, that owned audience was what she sold to first.
Key Lessons
Build an owned channel while the marketplace is still working, not after it stops. Hooley had a working website and social following for years before Etsy removed her shop. That head start is what let her recover in days instead of months. Our guide to leaving Etsy for your own store covers how to start that groundwork today.
A platform’s rules can change without warning. Etsy’s handmade policy was not new when it removed Bailey’s Blossoms, but enforcement caught up with a shop that had grown past what the platform was originally designed for. Sellers scaling a product line beyond strictly handmade goods carry this same risk.
Fee savings are only worth something if they get reinvested. Hooley didn’t pocket the margin freed up by leaving Etsy. She put it into email, SMS, and paid social, the channels that ended up driving the majority of 2020 revenue.
User-generated content can replace a marketing budget in the early years. The “Cutie Contest” strategy cost little beyond a gift-certificate incentive and produced hundreds of usable photos a month, according to Hooley’s account.
Diversifying into a second brand adds growth, but also adds forecasting risk. The $2 million inventory loss on Peyton Bre’s launch shows that a proven playbook from one brand does not automatically transfer cleanly to a new one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Was Bailey’s Blossoms removed from Etsy, or did Erin Hooley choose to leave?
Etsy removed the shop in December 2015, ruling that the ready-to-wear children’s clothing line no longer met the platform’s handmade requirements, according to Hooley’s interview with Mixergy. The exit was not planned by the seller.
How much did revenue change after Bailey’s Blossoms left Etsy?
Hooley has said sales on her own website reached three to four times their prior level within 48 hours of the move, and the business posted 233% year-over-year growth in 2016, the year the shift happened (Mixergy).
How can other Etsy sellers apply this to their own shop?
Start building an email list, a Facebook or Instagram following, and a standalone website while Etsy is still generating steady sales, not after a policy change or suspension forces the issue. See our guide on building an email list before leaving Etsy for a starting checklist.
How long did it take Bailey’s Blossoms to recover after losing its Etsy shop?
Based on Hooley’s account, meaningful recovery happened within 48 hours of shifting sales to her own website, though rebuilding to full scale took longer and included the 2018 launch of the Peyton Bre sister brand.
Does this approach work for sellers of genuinely handmade goods, not just ready-to-wear items?
The underlying lesson, that an owned audience protects a shop when a marketplace changes its rules, applies regardless of product type. Handmade sellers face the same fee structure and the same risk of depending on one channel for most of their revenue.
What platform did Bailey’s Blossoms move to after Etsy?
Hooley moved the business to her own standalone e-commerce website, which she had already been running in parallel with the Etsy shop since the business’s first week, according to Starter Story.
What would Erin Hooley have done differently, based on her own account?
She has pointed to the Peyton Bre inventory forecasting as the clearest misstep, saying overly optimistic projections for the new label’s direct-to-consumer launch led to roughly $2 million in losses that a more conservative first order could have avoided.
What’s the biggest mistake to avoid if most of your revenue comes from one marketplace?
Waiting until a suspension, policy change, or fee increase forces the decision. Bailey’s Blossoms only recovered as fast as it did because the owned website and audience already existed before Etsy removed the shop.
What’s the single most important step in this case study?
Building the website and Facebook following in the business’s first week, years before they were needed. That early, unglamorous groundwork is what turned a shop removal from a business-ending event into a 48-hour disruption.
Is this still a realistic path for Etsy sellers in 2026?
The core mechanics have not changed. Etsy can still remove listings or shops that fall outside its handmade or reselling policies, and sellers who have already built an owned audience are the ones who can absorb that risk. Our Etsy Star Seller Program guide covers another way Etsy’s own rules can shift under a seller with little notice.
Does leaving Etsy mean giving up marketplace sales entirely?
Not necessarily. Bailey’s Blossoms’ recovery was built around its own website, but sellers weighing a similar move can also compare other marketplaces rather than relying on a single channel again. Our roundup of Etsy alternatives covers the options.
How much does it cost to set up a website and following like Bailey’s Blossoms had?
Hooley’s site and Facebook page went live within five days of launching the Etsy shop in 2009, using basic e-commerce tools available at the time. The ongoing cost was mostly time spent on photo contests and customer engagement rather than a large advertising budget, based on her account of the early years.
The Bottom Line
Bailey’s Blossoms didn’t survive losing its Etsy shop because of a clever last-minute pivot. It survived because Erin Hooley had spent years building a website and an audience she owned outright, long before she needed either one. When Etsy pulled the shop in December 2015, that groundwork is what turned a potential business-ending event into 233% year-over-year growth.
The lesson for any Etsy seller reading this isn’t “leave Etsy.” It’s “don’t let Etsy be the only place your customers can find you.” Compare your current Etsy fee structure against an independent store to see how much margin is available to reinvest in the channels you actually control.
Related Articles
- How Boredwalk Grew From an Etsy Shop to a $3.5M Brand: another Etsy seller who built an owned store before a platform change forced the issue
- How Peg and Awl Grew From an Etsy Shop to a Wholesale Brand: a different diversification path, from Etsy into wholesale accounts
- 9 Proven Etsy SEO Techniques for 2026: tactics for sellers who plan to stay on Etsy while building a second channel
About This Research
Nadia Cole has spent the better part of a decade elbow-deep in marketplace algorithms, first optimizing Etsy shops for other sellers, then writing about what actually works instead of what sounds good in a blog post.
This article is based on publicly available, on-the-record interviews Erin Hooley gave to Mixergy and Starter Story, cross-referenced with Inc.’s reporting on the company’s Inc. 5000 ranking for consistency on the revenue figures and timeline. No figures in this piece were estimated or invented; every number is attributed to its original source.
Content reviewed and updated: 2026-09-22
Want More Marketplace Tips?
Join the newsletter — new guides drop regularly.